Cost avoidance vs. cost savings: differences, formulas, and examples

By: Matthew Barnum,

Claim Your FREE Spend Analysis

A $600 Value. Complimentary for a Limited Time

Cost savings is lower spend on the same goods or services, measured against what the company paid before: a unit price cut from $100 to $85 shows in the books as a smaller cost line. Cost avoidance measures a price increase the company prevented, such as a 10% increase held to 3%; it protects the budget, but no line item goes down. Finance teams call the first hard savings, a spend reduction visible in the accounts, and the second soft savings, value that never appears as a lower line item.

One classification rule settles most procurement cost savings vs cost avoidance debates: report avoidance in its own column, never inside the savings figure.

cost-saving-thumb

What is the difference between cost avoidance and cost savings?

Cost avoidance and cost savings differ in their baseline, the reference cost that a saving or an avoided cost is measured against. Cost savings compares the new price with the price you paid before; cost avoidance compares it with a higher price the supplier announced and you never paid. So cost avoidance is not the same as savings, even when both come out of one negotiation.

Dimension

Cost savings

Cost avoidance

Nature

Hard savings

Soft savings

Timing

Lower spend now

Prevents a future increase

Baseline

The price you paid before

The price the supplier announced

Formula

(Old price minus new price) × volume

(Announced price minus price paid) × volume

Evidence needed

Invoices and purchase orders

A written increase notice or quote

Visibility in the profit and loss (P&L) statement

A lower cost line

No change in the cost line

Who usually signs off

Finance confirms from the books

Finance accepts on documented evidence

 

The P&L statement shows revenue, costs, and profit for a period, so a saving lowers a cost line there while an avoided increase leaves the line where it was. That is why finance teams accept hard savings at face value and ask for evidence before they accept avoidance.

What does cost savings mean in procurement?

Cost savings in procurement is a measurable drop in what a company pays for the same goods or services, compared with a past baseline such as the previous contract price. Procurement teams also call it hard savings, and finance teams often use the term realized savings once the lower price appears in actual spend. Hard savings, realized savings, and spend reduction are all better words for "cost savings" when a report needs one.

Purchasing cost savings count when the new price is in purchase orders and invoices, because those records let finance trace each dollar. A negotiated price that nobody has bought at yet is a forecast, and procurement reports it as realized savings only after invoices at the new price arrive. That audit trail makes cost savings the easier metric to defend in a budget review.

How do I calculate cost savings?

You calculate cost savings by multiplying the drop in unit price by the volume you buy at the new price:

Cost savings = (old unit price minus new unit price) × volume bought at the new price

Cost savings percentage = (old unit price minus new unit price) ÷ old unit price × 100

A worked example with a unit price that falls from $100 to $85 on 2,000 units a year:

1. Saving per unit: $100 minus $85 = $15.

2. Annual saving: $15 × 2,000 units = $30,000 a year.

3. Percentage: $15 ÷ $100 = 15%.

The $30,000 stays a forecast until the units are bought. If the company buys 1,800 units at the new price, the realized saving is $27,000, and that invoiced figure is the one finance will accept.

What is cost avoidance?

Cost avoidance is a prevented price increase or new cost, measured against the price the supplier announced or quoted rather than against anything the company paid before. It is soft savings and proactive work: the cost line in the P&L statement does not go down; it rises less than the supplier planned. Other terms for cost avoidance include soft savings, cost containment, and price increase avoidance.

Avoidance also carries into later years. When a renewal starts from the current rate, an increase held off this year keeps the base lower for every later renewal. A 6% increase avoided on a $500,000 contract keeps $30,000 out of this year's spend and out of the starting point for next year's negotiation, which is how cost avoidance protects next year's budget as well as this one.

How to calculate cost avoidance

Cost avoidance equals the price increase you prevented, multiplied by the volume it would have applied to:

Cost avoidance = (price the supplier announced minus price you pay) × volume

The baseline is the announced price, so the calculation needs a written increase notice or quote; without one, there is no figure to measure against. A worked example on $200,000 of annual spend:

1. The supplier's written notice states a 10% increase, which would take annual spend to $220,000.

2. The buyer negotiates the increase down to 3%, so annual spend becomes $206,000.

3. Avoided cost: $220,000 minus $206,000 = $14,000.

4. As a share of the original spend: $14,000 ÷ $200,000 = 7%.

The 3% that went through ($6,000) is still an added cost and goes into no savings column; the $14,000 goes into the avoidance column only.

A multi-year cap works the same way, year by year. With a $10,000 annual rate, expected increases of 20% a year, and a contract cap of 10% after year one, years two and three cost $23,100 instead of $26,400: the cap avoids $3,300, or 12.5% of the expected cost.

Cost reduction vs. cost avoidance vs. cost savings

Cost reduction is a lasting lower cost base, usually from changing what or how the company buys (fewer suppliers, a lower specification, or less volume), while cost savings compares prices and cost avoidance compares against an announced increase. A cost reduction can lower total spend even when no unit price changes, for example when the company buys less volume.

Dimension

Cost savings

Cost avoidance

Cost reduction

What it measures

A lower price for the same purchase

An increase prevented before it applies

A smaller cost base from buying differently

Baseline

The price paid before

The supplier's announced price

Total spend before the change

How long it lasts

Until prices change again

A set window, such as 12 months

As long as the change stays

Typical example

A lower unit price

Capped renewal; maintenance that prevents emergency repairs

Consolidating suppliers; changing a specification

 

A lower specification counts as cost reduction only when total cost of ownership, meaning the price plus running and replacement costs, falls as well. Supplier consolidation, specification changes, and the other cost-saving strategies have their own guide on this site.

What is an example of cost avoidance in procurement?

A software renewal held at the old price after the vendor announced a 7% increase is a standard example of cost avoidance in procurement. The same contract can produce savings, avoidance, or both, and the baseline decides which column each dollar goes in:

Case

What happened

Counts as

Math

Nitrile gloves for a hospital network (safety and personal protective equipment)

The price drops from $24.00 to $21.60 a box on 5,000 boxes a year

Cost savings (hard)

$2.40 × 5,000 = $12,000 a year, 10%

Telecom plan consolidation

400 mobile lines move from $55 to $42 a month

Cost savings (hard)

$13 × 400 × 12 = $62,400 a year

Software subscription renewal

The vendor's renewal notice adds 7% to a $150,000 subscription; the buyer renews at the old price

Cost avoidance (soft)

7% × $150,000 = $10,500

Freight fuel surcharge

The carrier proposes raising the surcharge from 18% to 22% of $500,000 in base freight; the contract caps it at 19%

Cost avoidance (soft)

3 points × $500,000 = $15,000 avoided; the 1-point rise ($5,000) is an added cost

Janitorial services renewal

The supplier's notice asks for 5% on a $240,000 contract; the buyer agrees to 2%

Cost avoidance (soft)

3 points × $240,000 = $7,200 avoided; the 2% ($4,800) is an added cost

Packaging supplies at a manufacturing plant

An index-linked price, one that moves with a published index named in the contract, is capped at 4% a year; the index rises 6.5% on $300,000 of spend

Cost avoidance (soft)

2.5 points × $300,000 = $7,500 avoided; the 4% ($12,000) is an added cost

 

The gloves and telecom cases are the examples of cost savings: both lower a price the company already paid. The other four lower nothing in the books, and a report that added them to the savings total would overstate hard savings by $40,200 in this set alone.

Cost avoidance strategies built into supplier contracts

Most cost avoidance is written into the supplier contract before any increase notice arrives:

  • Price holds and multi-year agreements. A price hold, or price lock, fixes a price for a set period; a fixed-price multi-year agreement extends it across renewals.
  • Economic price adjustment clauses. An economic price adjustment clause, or escalation clause, lets the price move up or down when a named cost, price list, or index changes. The Federal Acquisition Regulation (FAR), the rule set for United States federal purchasing, allows three bases: established prices, actual labor or material costs, or named cost indexes.
  • Caps and thresholds. FAR clause 52.216-4 (2017 version) caps total increases at 10% of the original unit price, with no limit on decreases, and allows no adjustment for a change under 3% of the total contract price. These are public federal values; commercial contracts negotiate their own.
  • Notice with supporting data. FAR clause 52.216-4 also requires notice within 60 days of a cost change, with its cause, date, and amount; commercial contracts can demand the same.
  • Index-linked pricing. The price follows a published index named in the contract, such as the Producer Price Index (PPI), a monthly Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) index of producer prices. The 2021 BLS guide for contracting parties advises naming the base period and notes that PPI data can be revised for up to 4 months and an index can be discontinued.
  • Most-favored-customer clause. The buyer gets any lower price the supplier offers to similar customers.
  • Preventive maintenance terms. Scheduled maintenance prevents emergency repair bills, which counts as avoidance.

Fuel is a frequent trigger for price adjustment clauses, and a separate guide shows how rising fuel costs pass into supplier price lists and which contract terms to review.

How do I measure cost avoidance?

You measure cost avoidance by fixing the announced price as the baseline before the negotiation ends and applying five reporting rules:

1. Keep written evidence of the planned increase (the supplier's notice, quote, or renewal offer) before the negotiation closes.

2. Fix the baseline at the announced price and its date, and do not move it later.

3. Count the avoidance over a set window, such as 12 months from the effective date, then stop counting. Each team sets its own window; no standard requires 12 months.

4. Report avoidance in its own column, apart from hard savings.

5. Count each avoided increase once: do not count it again at renewal, and do not add it to a savings figure.

Even with these rules, avoidance stays a soft figure, because it never lowers a cost line, and some finance teams will still weigh it below hard savings. Leaving it out costs more. A report that shows hard savings only makes a team that held prices flat in a year of rising prices look idle, and it hides the value of every cap and price hold in the contract file. In Deloitte's 2023 Global Chief Procurement Officer Survey, only 30% of chief procurement officers met their cost savings targets, down from 50% in the previous study. The same survey describes staving off price increases as a procurement result that is hard to estimate and communicate, and the five rules give that result a number finance can check.

How group purchasing adds to both columns

A group purchasing organization (GPO), an organization that combines the purchasing volume of many members to negotiate supplier agreements, produces cost savings through pooled volume and cost avoidance through the price protection in those agreements. Pooled volume lowers unit prices below what one company would get alone. Multi-year price protection with indexed pricing and caps keeps members from increases they would face on their own, and members report that as avoidance.

At CenterPoint Group, we pool over $1 billion in collective indirect spend for our members, with no long-term contracts and no purchase minimums. Our agreements cover maintenance, repair, and operations (MRO) and industrial supplies, safety and personal protective equipment, recurring software expenses, telecom, facilities services, packaging solutions, and office supplies, and they are built to drive price stability and prevent savings leakage. Price holds and caps in a buyer's own supplier contracts still create avoidance, member or not.

If you want to see which of your current supplier agreements could add to either column, schedule a call with our team and we will walk through them with you.

 

Contact Us

CenterPoint Group provides savings solutions in key procurement categories, such as Office Supplies, MRO and Safety, Corporate Travel, Wireless Telecommunication,  Shipping and Small Parcel, Contingent Labor, Environmental services and more. Here are a few of our preferred suppliers:

CPG Supplier Logo Footer

 

Schedule Your FREE Consultation

A $400 Value. Complimentary for a Limited Time